How Do You Know When You Should Increase Rent?


As a landlord, one of your primary goals is to maximize the return on your investment. This often requires the delicate task of increasing rental rates at regular intervals. However, implementing a rental increase calls for careful strategic planning to avoid the risk of losing valuable tenants. This comprehensive guide aims to provide landlords with an insightful roadmap to navigate the intricacies of rental increase, including determining when and how much to increase rent, legal considerations, and strategies to maintain tenant satisfaction during the process.

Understanding the Importance of Rental Increase

The first step in the process is understanding the significance of rental increases. As a landlord, your rental income should not only cover your property-related expenses but also yield a profit. With inflation and escalating costs in real estate, it becomes necessary to raise rents periodically. The expenses that necessitate a rental increase typically include:

  • Property taxes
  • Mortgage payments
  • Insurance premiums
  • Property management fees
  • Maintenance, repairs, and upgrades
  • Homeowners Association (HOA) fees, if applicable
  • Utilities, if included in the rent

If these costs are not accounted for in the rental income, it could significantly impact your profitability.

Assessing Market Rent: The Starting Point

Before considering a rental increase, it is crucial to understand the current market rent. This is the competitive rental rate for similar properties in your local area. Assessing the market rent ensures that your proposed rental increase aligns with current market trends and doesn’t exceed the local rental rates, which could lead to tenant dissatisfaction and potential vacancies.

Several free resources can be used to check local rental comparisons, such as Zillow, Craigslist, PropStream, and Mashvisor. These platforms can help landlords analyze the local rental market, compare similar properties, and establish a competitive and reasonable rental price.

(Or you can contact Homeward Property Management for a professional rental analysis!)

The Crucial Question: How Much to Raise the Rent?

Once you’ve established the market rent, the next step is determining how much to increase the rent. A general rule of thumb is not to increase the rent by more than 5% per year. Any sharp increase above this threshold could lead tenants to consider moving out, even if the new rental rate aligns with the market rate.

For instance, if your current rent is $1000 per month and the market rate is $1100, consider raising the rent by $50 this year and another $50 the next year. This gradual increase is less likely to cause tenant dissatisfaction and potential turnover.

Bear in mind, landlords should never raise the rent by more than 10% if they wish to retain their tenants. Most tenants’ budgets cannot accommodate a sudden, significant increase in monthly expenses, making this an important consideration when planning a rental increase.

Timing the Rent Increase: A Strategic Decision

The timing of the rent increase is another key factor landlords need to consider. The best time to increase rent is typically at the end of a leasing period, aligning with the renewal of the lease agreement. This allows for a smooth transition and gives the tenant sufficient time to plan their budget.

It’s also essential to comply with any lease agreement stipulations or state laws regarding the notice period for rent increases. The notice period often ranges from 30 to 60 days, although it can sometimes be as long as 90 or 120 days. Providing ample notice not only ensures legal compliance but also helps maintain a positive landlord-tenant relationship.

Communicating the Rent Increase: Transparency is Key

When it comes to informing your tenants about a rental increase, clear and professional communication is crucial. Written notification, usually in the form of a rent increase letter, is often the best approach. This not only provides a clear reference but also ensures that all necessary information is conveyed, leaving no room for confusion or misunderstanding.

The rent increase letter should include the following details:

  • The amount of the rent increase
  • The date when the increase will take effect
  • The reasons for the increase
  • Any incentives or options for early lease renewal

When explaining the reasons for the increase, landlords can mention any rising costs or property improvements that necessitate the increase. This transparency can help tenants understand the rationale behind the increase and its potential benefits in the long run.

Dealing with Tenant Complaints: A Proactive Approach

Despite your best efforts, some tenants may voice concerns or complaints about the rental increase. In such cases, it’s essential to respond proactively and empathetically. Here are a few strategies to consider:

  • Offer a lower increase if they renew their lease early. This gives tenants a sense of control and encourages early lease renewal.
  • Provide non-cash incentives for renewal, such as gift cards or property upgrades.
  • Educate tenants about market rates and how your new rental rate still offers competitive value.
  • Remind the tenant of the costs associated with moving to a new property (e.g., security deposit, first and last months’ rent), emphasizing that a slight rent increase may still be financially advantageous.

Legal Considerations: Staying on the Right Side of the Law

Landlords must also be mindful of any legal limitations or requirements related to rental increases. These can vary significantly between states and even cities, making it vital to familiarize yourself with local landlord-tenant laws. In general, landlords should be aware of the following legal considerations:

  • Many jurisdictions require landlords to provide written notice of a rent increase, typically 30 to 60 days in advance.
  • Some areas have rent control laws that limit how much and how often landlords can increase rent.
  • Increasing rent as a retaliatory act or as a form of discrimination is illegal under the Fair Housing Act.
  • Landlords cannot raise rent during the term of a fixed-term lease unless the lease specifically allows for it.

By staying informed about these legal considerations, landlords can navigate rent increases in a lawful and ethical manner.

Striking the Right Balance

In conclusion, increasing rent is a strategic decision that requires careful planning and execution. The key is to strike a balance between maximizing your return on investment and maintaining tenant satisfaction. By understanding the market rent, setting a reasonable increase, timing the increase appropriately, communicating transparently with tenants, and adhering to legal requirements, landlords can successfully navigate the process of rental increase, ensuring a win-win outcome for both parties.

Whether you’re a seasoned landlord or new to property management, this guide equips you with the necessary knowledge and strategies to implement rental increases in an effective and tenant-friendly manner. After all, successful property management is not just about maximizing profits but also about fostering positive, long-term relationships with your tenants.


Let our experts analyze your rental property and provide a completely free report.

We’ll never share or sell your information. Check out our Privacy Policy here.